Home
Scholarly Works
Systematic Reviews in Name Only? Misleading...
Preprint

Systematic Reviews in Name Only? Misleading Evidence Assessments in Pediatric Gender Medicine

Abstract

Most systematic reviews of interventions for pediatric gender dysphoria have found the evidence for psychological benefits to be highly uncertain. However, some reviews have concluded that puberty blockers and/or cross-sex hormones improve mental health. Two recent examples in the latter category are the University of Utah College of Pharmacy Drug Regimen Review Center's 2025 review, Gender-Affirming Medical Treatments for Pediatric Patients With Gender Dysphoria, and Tornese et al., published in Frontiers in Endocrinology in 2025. These publications present themselves as systematic reviews but fail to complete-or adequately complete-the final, essential steps: evidence synthesis and formal assessment of evidence certainty. Because systematic reviews sit atop the evidence pyramid, publications like the Utah Review and Tornese et al., which are systematic reviews in name only, can mislead clinicians, patients, parents, guideline developers, and policymakers about the true state of the evidence.

Authors

Zhang Y; Cohn J; Kulatunga Moruzi C; Pignard M; McDeavitt K

Publication date

January 1, 2026

DOI

10.2139/ssrn.7536460

Preprint server

SSRN Electronic Journal

Labels

Sustainable Development Goals (SDG)

View published work (Non-McMaster Users)