Variational principles for describing chemical reactions: Condensed reactivity indices

Two recent papers [P. W. Ayers and R. G. Parr, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 122, 2010 (2000); 123, 2007 (2001)] have shown how variational principles for the energy may be used to derive and elucidate the significance of the chemical reactivity indices of density-functional theory. Here, similar ideas are applied, yielding a systematic, mathematically rigorous, and physically sound approach to condensed reactivity indices. First, we use the variational principle for the energy to derive an expression for the condensed Fukui function index in terms of the condensed hardness kernel. Next, we address an important open problem pertaining to condensed reactivity indices: when (if ever) is the condensed Fukui function for an atom in a molecule negative? In particular, our analysis confirms the observation, hitherto based only on computational evidence, that the Hirshfeld partitioning is optimal for obtaining non-negative Fukui functions. We also hypothesize that the strong diagonal dominance of the condensed hardness kernel is sufficient for the non-negativity of the Fukui function. Errors in the partitioning of molecules into atoms and inadequate treatment of correlation are pinpointed as the most likely causes of negative condensed Fukui functions. We conclude by noting that the condensed Fukui functions are, in some respects, more appropriate indicators of a molecular site’s reactivity than the Fukui function itself.