Comparison of Patient Health Questionnaire-9, Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale and Hospital Anxiety and Depression – Depression subscale scores by administration mode: An individual participant data differential item functioning meta-analysis Journal Articles uri icon

  •  
  • Overview
  •  
  • Research
  •  
  • Identity
  •  
  • Additional Document Info
  •  
  • View All
  •  

abstract

  • Administration mode of patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) may influence responses. We assessed if Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9), Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS) and Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale - Depression subscale (HADS-D) item responses and scores were associated with administration mode. We compared (1) self-administration versus interview-administration; within self-administration (2) research or medical setting versus private; and (3) pen-and-paper versus electronic; and within interview-administration (4) in-person versus phone. We analysed individual participant data meta-analysis datasets with item-level data for the PHQ-9 (N = 34,529), EPDS (N = 16,813), and HADS-D (N = 16,768). We used multiple indicator multiple cause models to assess differential item functioning (DIF) by administration mode. We found statistically significant DIF for most items on all measures due to large samples, but influence on total scores was negligible. In 10 comparisons conducted across the PHQ-9, EPDS, and HADS-D, Pearson's correlations and intraclass correlation coefficients between latent depression symptom scores from models that did or did not account for DIF were between 0.995 and 1.000. Total PHQ-9, EPDS, and HADS-D scores did not differ materially across administration modes. Researcher and clinicians who evaluate depression symptoms with these questionnaires can select administration methods based on patient preferences, feasibility, or cost.

authors

  • Harel, Daphna
  • Wu, Yin
  • Levis, Brooke
  • Fan, Suiqiong
  • Sun, Ying
  • Xu, Mingyao
  • Rice, Danielle
  • Boruff, Jill
  • Markham, Sarah
  • Ioannidis, John PA
  • Takwoingi, Yemisi
  • Patten, Scott B
  • Ziegelstein, Roy C
  • Cuijpers, Pim
  • Gilbody, Simon
  • Vigod, Simone
  • Akena, Dickens
  • Benedetti, Andrea
  • Thombs, Brett D
  • Azar, Marleine
  • Bhandari, Parash Mani
  • Chiovitti, Matthew J
  • He, Chen
  • Imran, Mahrukh
  • Krishnan, Ankur
  • Negeri, Zelalem
  • Neupane, Dipika
  • Riehm, Kira E
  • Yan, Xin Wei
  • Kloda, Lorie A
  • Henry, Melissa
  • Ismail, Zahinoor
  • Loiselle, Carmen G
  • Mitchell, Nicholas D
  • Al-Adawi, Samir
  • Alvarado, Rubén
  • Amtmann, Dagmar
  • Arroll, Bruce
  • Ayalon, Liat
  • Baradaran, Hamid R
  • Barnes, Jacqueline
  • Beck, Kevin R
  • Beck, Cheryl Tatano
  • Bernstein, Charles N
  • Bindt, Carola
  • Bombardier, Charles H
  • Boye, Birgitte
  • Büel-Drabe, Natalie
  • Buji, Ryna Imma
  • Bunevicius, Adomas
  • Butterworth, Peter
  • Can, Ceyhun
  • Carter, Gregory
  • Chagas, Marcos H
  • Chan, Juliana CN
  • Chan, Lai Fong
  • Chen, Chih-Ken
  • Chibanda, Dixon
  • Chorwe-Sungani, Genesis
  • Clover, Kerrie
  • Conroy, Ronán M
  • Conway, Aaron
  • Conwell, Yeates
  • Correa, Humberto
  • Couto, Thiago Castro E
  • Cukor, Daniel
  • Daray, Federico M
  • de Man-van Ginkel, Janneke M
  • De Souza, Jennifer
  • Downing, Marina G
  • Eapen, Valsamma
  • Fann, Jesse R
  • Favez, Nicolas
  • Felice, Ethel
  • Fellmeth, Gracia
  • Ferentinos, Panagiotis P
  • Fernandes, Michelle
  • Field, Sally
  • Figueiredo, Barbara
  • Fischer, Felix H
  • Fisher, Jane RW
  • Flint, Alastair J
  • Fujimori, Maiko
  • Fung, Daniel SS
  • Gallagher, Pamela
  • Gandy, Milena
  • Gelaye, Bizu
  • Gholizadeh, Leila
  • Gibson, Lorna J
  • Goodyear-Smith, Felicity
  • Grassi, Luigi
  • Green, Eric P
  • Greeno, Catherine G
  • Hall, Brian J
  • Hantsoo, Liisa
  • Haroz, Emily E
  • Härter, Martin
  • Hegerl, Ulrich
  • Helle, Nadine
  • Hernando, Asuncion
  • Hides, Leanne
  • Hobfoll, Stevan E
  • Honikman, Simone
  • Howard, Louise M
  • Hyphantis, Thomas
  • Iglesias-González, Maria
  • Inagaki, Masatoshi
  • Jenewein, Josef
  • Jeon, Hong Jin
  • Jetté, Nathalie
  • Julião, Miguel
  • Kettunen, Pirjo A
  • Khamseh, Mohammad E
  • Kiely, Kim M
  • Kim, Sung-Wan
  • Kjærgaard, Marie
  • Kohlhoff, Jane
  • Kohrt, Brandon A
  • König, Hans-Helmut
  • Kozinszky, Zoltán
  • Kwan, Yunxin
  • Lamers, Femke
  • Lara, María Asunción
  • Leonardou, Angeliki A
  • Levin-Aspenson, Holly F
  • Liu, Shen-Ing
  • Löbner, Margrit
  • Loosman, Wim L
  • Lotrakul, Manote
  • Loureiro, Sonia R
  • Love, Anthony W
  • Löwe, Bernd
  • Luitel, Nagendra P
  • Lund, Crick
  • Maes, Michael
  • Malt, Ulrik F
  • Marrie, Ruth Ann
  • Marsh, Laura
  • Martínez, Pablo
  • Marx, Brian P
  • Matsuoka, Yutaka
  • McGuire, Anthony
  • Mehnert, Anja
  • Michopoulos, Ioannis
  • Sidik, Sherina Mohd
  • Müller-Nordhorn, Jacqueline
  • Muramatsu, Kumiko
  • Radoš, Sandra Nakić
  • Navarrete, Laura
  • Nelson, Christian J
  • Ng, Chong Guan
  • Nishi, Daisuke
  • O'Donnell, Meaghan L
  • O'Rourke, Suzanne J
  • Osório, Flávia L
  • Pabst, Alexander
  • Pasco, Julie A
  • Pawlby, Susan J
  • Peceliuniene, Jurate
  • Pence, Brian W
  • Persoons, Philippe
  • Petersen, Inge
  • Picardi, Angelo
  • Ponsford, Jennie L
  • Pugh, Stephanie L
  • Pulido, Federico
  • Hernando, Asuncion
  • Quinn, Terence J
  • Quispel, Chantal
  • Rathod, Sujit D
  • Reme, Silje E
  • Reuter, Katrin
  • Riedel-Heller, Steffi G
  • Rooney, Alasdair G
  • Santos, Iná S
  • Saracino, Rebecca M
  • Schellekens, Melanie PJ
  • Schwarzbold, Marcelo L
  • Cankorur, Vesile Senturk
  • Shaaban, Juwita
  • Sharp, Deborah J
  • Sharpe, Louise
  • Shinn, Eileen H
  • Sidebottom, Abbey
  • Simard, Sébastien
  • Singer, Susanne
  • Skalkidou, Alkistis
  • Smith-Nielsen, Johanne
  • Spangenberg, Lena
  • Stafford, Lesley
  • Stein, Alan
  • Stewart, Robert C
  • Strobel, Natalie A
  • Su, Kuan-Pin
  • Sultan, Serge
  • Sundström-Poromaa, Inger
  • Sung, Sharon C
  • Suzuki, Keiko
  • Tadinac, Meri
  • Tan, Pei Lin Lynnette
  • Tandon, S Darius
  • Taylor-Rowan, Martin
  • Teixeira, Antonio L
  • Tendais, Iva
  • Tiringer, Istvan
  • Töreki, Annamária
  • Tran, Thach D
  • Trevillion, Kylee
  • Tschorn, Mira
  • Turner, Alyna
  • Væver, Mette S
  • van der Feltz-Cornelis, Christina M
  • van Heyningen, Thandi
  • Vega-Dienstmaier, Johann M
  • Wagner, Michael
  • Wagner, Lynne I
  • Wang, Liang-Jen
  • Wang, Jian Li
  • Watson, David
  • Weyerer, Siegfried B
  • White, Jennifer
  • Whooley, Mary A
  • Wiese, Birgitt
  • Williams, Lana J
  • Winkley, Kirsty
  • Wynter, Karen
  • Yamada, Mitsuhiko
  • Yonkers, Kimberly A
  • Zeng, Qing Zhi
  • Zhang, Yuying

publication date

  • September 2024