Skeletal Mg/Ca in Primnoa resedaeformis: relationship to temperature?

It has been suggested that the deep-sea gorgonian coral Primnoa resedaeformis may be an important paleoceanographic archive. Seventeen colonies collected from the upper slope of the NW Atlantic margin (229 – 447 m) were analyzed to see if skeletal Mg/Ca is related to temperature. Analyses were focused on the calcite cortex region of skeletal sections to avoid interference from organic Mg in the horny layers found closer to the center of sections. Comparison of bulk skeletal Mg/Ca with hydrographic temperature yielded the relationship Mg/Ca (mmol/mol)=5 (+/− 1.4) T (°C)+64 (+/− 10). This relationship was used to calibrate profiles of Mg/Ca measured across the annual rings of one large, well-dated colony, over the period 1950–2002. Mg/Ca profiles were broadly consistent among three sections spaced 10 cm apart along the main trunk of the colony. These profiles were in general agreement with the local instrumental record of temperature at 375 – 450 m. Some discrepancies between the coral and instrumental records of temperature may be a result of chronological error, poor sampling density, or additional factors influencing Mg partitioning in the coral. Overall, these preliminary results support the hypothesis that temperature drives Mg/Ca in the skeletal calcite of this species. It appears that environmentally meaningful records from Primnoa resedaeformis will be found at decadal scales or longer.