Comparison of Prophylactic Intravenous Antibiotic Regimens After Endoprosthetic Reconstruction for Lower Extremity Bone Tumors Academic Article uri icon

  •  
  • Overview
  •  
  • Research
  •  
  • Identity
  •  
  • Additional Document Info
  •  
  • View All
  •  

abstract

  • Importance

    The use of perioperative, prophylactic, intravenous antibiotics is standard practice to reduce the risk of surgical site infection after oncologic resection and complex endoprosthetic reconstruction for lower extremity bone tumors. However, evidence guiding the duration of prophylactic treatment remains limited.

    Objective

    To assess the effect of a 5-day regimen of postoperative, prophylactic, intravenous antibiotics compared with a 1-day regimen on the rate of surgical site infections within 1 year after surgery.

    Design, setting, and participants

    This randomized clinical superiority trial was performed at 48 clinical sites in 12 countries from January 1, 2013, to October 29, 2019. The trial included patients with a primary bone tumor or a soft tissue sarcoma that had invaded the femur or tibia or oligometastatic bone disease of the femur or tibia with expected survival of at least 1 year who required surgical management by excision and endoprosthetic reconstruction. A total of 611 patients were enrolled, and 7 were excluded for ineligibility.

    Interventions

    A 1- or 5-day regimen of postoperative prophylactic intravenous cephalosporin (cefazolin or cefuroxime) that began within 8 hours after skin closure and was administered every 8 hours thereafter. Those randomized to the 1-day regimen received identical saline doses every 8 hours for the remaining 4 days; patients, care providers, and outcomes assessors were blinded to treatment regimen.

    Main outcomes and measures

    The primary outcome in this superiority trial was a surgical site infection (superficial incisional, deep incisional, or organ space) classified according to the criteria established by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention within 1 year after surgery. Secondary outcomes included antibiotic-related complications, unplanned additional operations, oncologic and functional outcomes, and mortality.

    Results

    Of the 604 patients included in the final analysis (mean [SD] age, 41.2 [21.9] years; 361 [59.8%] male; 114 [18.9%] Asian, 43 [7.1%] Black, 34 [5.6%] Hispanic, 15 [2.5%] Indigenous, 384 [63.8%] White, and 12 [2.0%] other), 293 were randomized to a 5-day regimen and 311 to a 1-day regimen. A surgical site infection occurred in 44 patients (15.0%) allocated to the 5-day regimen and in 52 patients (16.7%) allocated to the 1-day regimen (hazard ratio, 0.93; 95% CI, 0.62-1.40; P = .73). Antibiotic-related complications occurred in 15 patients (5.1%) in the 5-day regimen and in 5 patients (1.6%) allocated to the 1-day regimen (hazard ratio, 3.24; 95% CI, 1.17-8.98; P = .02). Other secondary outcomes did not differ significantly between treatment groups.

    Conclusions and relevance

    This randomized clinical trial did not confirm the superiority of a 5-day regimen of postoperative intravenous antibiotics over a 1-day regimen in preventing surgical site infections after surgery for lower extremity bone tumors that required an endoprosthesis. The 5-day regimen group had significantly more antibiotic-related complications.

    Trial registration

    ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT01479283.

authors

  • Ghert, Michelle
  • Schneider, Patricia
  • Giglio, Victoria
  • McKay, Paula
  • Duong, Andrew
  • Evaniew, Nathan
  • Ghanem, Dana
  • MacLeay, Callum
  • Madden, Kim
  • Racano, Antonella
  • Scott, Taryn
  • Swinton, Marilyn
  • Simunovic, Nicole
  • Sprague, Sheila
  • Heels-Ansdell, Diane
  • Buckingham, Lisa
  • Vélez, Roberto
  • Fernandez, Alba Lopez
  • Carrizo, Olga Sánchez-Maroto
  • Bhandari, Mohit
  • Deheshi, Benjamin
  • Guyatt, Gordon
  • Holt, Ginger
  • O'Shea, Timothy
  • Randall, R Lor
  • Thabane, Lehana
  • Wunder, Jay S
  • Turcotte, Robert
  • Wilson, David
  • Rose, Peter
  • Brigman, Brian
  • Pullenayegum, Eleanor
  • Ferguson, Peter C
  • Griffin, Anthony M
  • Grewal, Gagan
  • Han, Andrew
  • Mantas, Ionna
  • Wylie, Andrew
  • Goulding, Krista
  • Andersen, Nicole
  • Bouchereau, Olivier
  • Dandachli, Firas
  • Dessureault, Mireille
  • Salomon, Steven
  • Ste-Marie, Nathalie
  • Lessard, Ariane
  • Matte, Gilbert
  • Bond, Zoe
  • Lin, Bo Xuan
  • Biljan, Maya
  • Chan, Rita
  • Cosentino, Deanna
  • Lourenco, Diane
  • Marriott, Brittany
  • Sobhi, Gita
  • Isler, Marc
  • Mottard, Sophie
  • Barry, Janie
  • Saint-Yves, Hugo
  • Bétournay, Marysa
  • Quach, Marceline
  • Assayag, Helen
  • Daoust, Karine
  • Goyette, Kristine
  • Projean, Denis
  • Lum, Millie
  • Bachand-Fournier, Maude
  • Dion, Norbert
  • Arteau, Annie
  • Turmel, Sylvie
  • Bertrand, Anne
  • D'Amours, Manon
  • Dallaire, Lucie
  • Gagnon, Nancy
  • Gosselin, Lucie
  • Grenier, Gladys
  • Labbé, Véronique
  • Tran, Tuong-Vi
  • Clarkson, Paul
  • Kondo, Lisa
  • Wang, Baohua
  • Yip, Judy
  • Werier, Joel
  • Abdelbary, Hesham
  • Kassim, Yusra
  • Cosgrove, Heather
  • Paquin, Kimberly
  • Dugal, Anne-Marie
  • Fetzer, Susan
  • Aikens, Wendy
  • Puloski, Shannon
  • Monument, Michael
  • Carcary, Kimberly
  • Hazenbiller, Olesja
  • Kashluba, Kayla
  • Rodriguez, Jimena
  • Cameron, Candice
  • Doung, Yee-Cheen
  • Gundle, Kenneth
  • Hayden, James
  • Hart, Christopher
  • Jenkins, David
  • Wetzel, Rebecca I
  • Wolf, Krista
  • Bernard, Brooke
  • Blefgen, Sara
  • Jones, Kevin
  • Groundland, John
  • Crabtree, Susie
  • Hart, Jacqueline
  • Shaw, Sara
  • Davis, Rian
  • Redd, Winter
  • Sorenson, Susan
  • Miller, Benjamin
  • Milhem, Mohammed
  • Kain, Jill
  • Andersen, Marian
  • Hillburn, Kathryn
  • Larson, Jennifer
  • McCurdy, Nancy
  • Pratt, Alyssa
  • Schall, Mary
  • Hobbs, Theresa
  • Johnson, Kristine
  • Nohr, Joanna
  • Slaughter, Wendi
  • Halpern, Jennifer
  • Schwartz, Herbert
  • Daniels, Julie
  • Schafer, Eden
  • Moore, M Shane
  • Healey, John H
  • Chang, Kaity
  • Chen, Linda
  • Douvelis, Olivera
  • Galle, Jesse
  • Mezzancello, Marissa
  • Tavarez, Yoely
  • Del Corral, Brian
  • Lopez, Sabrina
  • O'Neill, Gerry
  • Abraham, John
  • Brown, Scot
  • Angelos, Meghan
  • Sobol, Keenan
  • Strony, John
  • Rall, Braden
  • Furio, Melissa
  • Sailor, Linda
  • Sadaka, Rania
  • Karel, Lauren
  • Geller, David
  • Hoang, Bang
  • Tingling, Janet
  • Solorzano, Clemencia
  • Wustrack, Rosanna
  • O'Donnell, Richard
  • Zimel, Melissa
  • Andaya, Veronica
  • Carrasco, Adrianna
  • Chen, Shirley
  • Ng, Diana
  • Koplowicz, Yelena
  • Spiguel, André
  • Chan, Chung Ming
  • Gibbs, Charles Parker
  • Scarborough, Mark
  • Horodyski, MaryBeth
  • Carmona, Johanna
  • Jackson, Alana
  • Struk, Aimee
  • Beltz, Susan
  • Giaquinta, Justin C
  • Johnson, Melissa
  • Cheng, Edward Y
  • Agel, Julie
  • Christiansen, Theresa
  • LaBar, Derek
  • Luke, Darlette
  • Avedian, Raffi
  • Jordan, Linda
  • Kenney, Deborah
  • Chinn, Steven
  • Hamilton, Martha
  • Mayeda, Scott
  • Morris, Carol
  • Levin, Adam
  • Albery, Kari
  • Giordano, Jennifer
  • Laljani, Vaishali
  • Delisa, Anne
  • Mesko, Nathan
  • Nystrom, Lukas
  • Rerko, Matthew
  • Keaney, Heather
  • Yim, Rachael
  • Petrich, John
  • Anderson, Megan E
  • Gebhardt, Mark C
  • Allar, Benjamin
  • Greenberg, Michael
  • Naqvi, Manahil
  • Prather, Ellis
  • Rademacher, Emily
  • Shea, Jodie
  • Bennett, James
  • Albuquerque, Stacey
  • Giarrusso, Michael
  • Aboulafia, Albert J
  • Wallace, Matthew T
  • Brown, Sally
  • Fowler, Janice
  • Flack, Jean
  • Battersby, Rick
  • Taylor, Chad
  • Greenberg, David
  • Dawson, Sarah
  • Riebeling, Adam
  • Schmidt, Anna
  • Henderson, Eric
  • DePalo, Peter
  • Mack, Lisa
  • Neely-Jones, Christine
  • Newton, Crystallee
  • Ressler, Daniel
  • Symonds, Holly
  • Gardner, Iryna
  • Parr, Douglas
  • Poisson, Victoria
  • Rozolsky, David
  • Teune, Patrick
  • Schwab, Joseph
  • Lozano-Calderon, Santiago A
  • Baker, Jonathan
  • Berner, Emily Ann
  • Im, Gi Hye
  • Kim, Jason
  • Park, Christine
  • Phukan, Rishabh
  • Wright, Zachary
  • Yeates, Sarah
  • Joshi, Lalit
  • Damron, Timothy
  • Craig, Tina
  • Reale, Melissa
  • DiCaprio, Matthew R
  • Palmer, Bradford A
  • Schaeffer, Toni
  • Cioppa, Elena
  • Neilson, John C
  • King, David M
  • Wooldridge, Adam N
  • Gonzalez, Karen C
  • Ellestad, Marie
  • Lewis, Kate
  • Nelson, Tom
  • Reimer, Nickolas
  • Monson, David
  • Oskouei, Shervin
  • Lomba, Christina
  • Glenney, Lauren
  • Rogers, Susan
  • Goodman, Howard
  • McGill, Marlena
  • Olivares, Peter
  • Petruccelli, Francesca
  • Afzal, Uzma
  • Faynblat, Zina
  • Mathew, Elizabeth
  • Bell-Farrell, Wanda
  • Bosley, Judith
  • Hughes, Corilynn
  • Ikiddeh-Barnes, Ukeme
  • Jones, Ashley
  • Loomis, Melissa
  • Solis, Alexis
  • Wade, Christine
  • Friedman, Stephanie
  • Nzelibe, Chukwuemeka N
  • Wagner, Katiri
  • Jolin, Hina A
  • Patel, Heena
  • Sorger, Joel
  • Leitsinger, Nichole
  • Carpenter, Krista
  • LaGory, Denise
  • Thorpe, Steven
  • Nichols, Shari Lynn
  • Febre, Patrick
  • Monares, Jacob
  • Nguyen, Kimmai
  • Sarwary, Nadir
  • Trovitch, Peter
  • Bernthal, Nicholas
  • Eckardt, Jeffrey
  • Hornicek, Francis
  • Zoller, Stephen
  • Kiel, Gloria
  • Madamba, Jason
  • Shin, Christina
  • Lindsay, Adam
  • Fish-Fuhrmann, Jamie
  • Culbertson, Maya
  • Caruso-Prendergast, Patricia
  • Garling, Emily
  • Nicholas, Richard
  • Montgomery, Corey
  • Holley, J Aaron
  • Jones, Rachel
  • McAdoo, Melissa
  • Wade, Daisy
  • Caid, Mindy
  • Crisp, Amy
  • Roberts, Jennifer
  • Balach, Tess
  • Cote, Mark
  • Coyle, Kathleen
  • Rushlow, Kelly
  • LaCasse, Ruth
  • Lerman, Daniel
  • Howe, Andrea
  • Patel, Prashant
  • Phan, Andrew
  • Telscher, Shinyi
  • Weiss, Kurt
  • Goodman, Mark
  • Heyl, Alma
  • Korenoski, Chris
  • Yeschke, Chris Ann
  • Scharschmidt, Thomas
  • Mayerson, Joel
  • Crist, Martha
  • Barr, Hallie
  • Khan, Shah Alam
  • Sampath Kumar, Venkatesan
  • Agarwal, Abhinav
  • Banjara, Roshan
  • Oli, Sanjay
  • Baptista, André Mathias
  • Pires de Camargo, Olavo
  • Zumárraga, Juan Pablo
  • Freitar, Juliana
  • Agomes, Ismael
  • Dijkstra, PD Sander
  • van de Sande, Michiel
  • Sanders, Philip
  • Bosma, Sarah
  • Toi, Marieke Afra
  • Serra, Marcos Galli
  • Parizzia, Walter
  • Marinsalta, Gabriela
  • Podrzaj, Angela
  • Torres, Mariana Foa
  • Pérez, Manuel
  • Brumós, Lourdes Girona
  • Suñé, Pilar
  • Rodseth, Reitze
  • Marais, Leonard
  • Nieuwoudt, Luan
  • Rajah, Chantal
  • Gumede, Simphiwe
  • Leithner, Andreas
  • Bergovec, Marko
  • Fink, Andrea
  • Halb, Carina
  • El Ghoneimy, Ahmed
  • Elgalaly, Dina
  • Kamal, Nehal
  • Becker, Ricardo
  • Antunes, Bruno Pereira
  • Galia, Carlos Roberto
  • Santos, Julie F Cerutti
  • Fasolo, Daniel
  • Tan, Mann Hong
  • Zainul Abidin, Suraya
  • Cheang, Lai Ye
  • Clayer, Mark
  • Jagiello, Jakub
  • Morris, David
  • Chai, Yee
  • Duong, Steven
  • Nguyen, Tran
  • Slobodian, Peter
  • Jutte, Paul
  • Zuur, Marlanka
  • Ghert, Michelle
  • Schneider, Patricia
  • Guyatt, Gordon
  • Thabane, Lehana
  • Vélez, Roberto
  • O’Shea, Timothy
  • Randall, R Lor
  • Turcotte, Robert
  • Wilson, David
  • Wunder, Jay S
  • Baptista, André Mathias
  • Cheng, Edward Y
  • Doung, Yee-Cheen
  • Ferguson, Peter C
  • Giglio, Victoria
  • Hayden, James
  • Heels-Ansdell, Diane
  • Khan, Shah Alam
  • Sampath Kumar, Venkatesan
  • McKay, Paula
  • Miller, Benjamin
  • van de Sande, Michiel
  • Zumárraga, Juan P
  • Bhandari, Mohit

publication date

  • March 1, 2022