Ovarian aging is characterized by mitochondrial dysfunction, oxidative stress, and inflammation. The development of adjunctive treatments that mitigate age-related subfertility is warranted. We examined the benefits of nutraceutical supplementation (FE; Fertility Enhancer) with mitochondrial antioxidants, anti-inflammatory agents, metabolic activators, vitamins and minerals, and amino acids on ovarian aging, metabolic activity, and reproductive success in young (Y; 6-month-old) and middle-aged (O; 11-month-old) female C57BL/6J mice. The mice were fed calorie- and macronutrient-matched diets w/wo the FE supplement for three months and harem mated twice. Daily FE supplementation promoted significant body re-composition, including loss of white adipose tissue (gWAT: -36% vs. CON, p < 0.001), gain of skeletal muscle (SkM: +67% vs. CON, p < 0.001), and improved SkM/gWAT ratio (+185% vs. CON, p < 0.001). Metabolic testing showed enhanced fat oxidation (+38%, p < 0.01) and energy expenditure (+7%, p = 0.051) in FE mice. Breeding and immunoblotting data demonstrated improved reproductive success (Y-CON: 44%, Y-FE: 89%, O-CON: 0%, O-FE: 18%) and a modest attenuation of ovarian aging markers in both FE groups. We surmise that a multi-ingredient supplement, such as the Fertility Enhancer, may improve body re-composition, metabolic activity, and markers of ovarian aging, thus enhancing reproductive health and fertility in females.