First and Second Order Recursion on Abstract Data Types

This paper compares two scheme-based models of computation on abstract many-sorted algebras A: Feferman's system ACP(A) of "abstract computational procedures" based on a least fixed point operator, and Tucker and Zucker's system μPR(A) based on primitive recursion on the naturals together with a least number operator. We prove a conjecture of Feferman that (assuming contains sorts for natural numbers and arrays of data) the two systems are equivalent. The main step in the proof is showing the equivalence of both systems to a system Rec(A) of computation by an imperative programming language with recursive calls. The result provides a confirmation for a Generalized Church-Turing Thesis for computation on abstract data types.