PRISMA flow diagrams for living systematic...

PRISMA flow diagrams for living systematic reviews: a methodological survey and a proposal

Abstract

Background : While the PRISMA flow diagram is widely used for reporting standard systematic reviews (SRs), it was not designed for capturing the results of continual searches for studies in living systematic reviews (LSRs). The objectives of this study are (1) to assess how published LSRs report on the flow of studies through the different phases of the review for the different updates; (2) to propose an approach to reporting on that flow. Methods : For objective 1, we identified all LSRs published up to July 2020. We abstracted information regarding their general characteristics and how they reported on search results. For objective 2, we based our proposal for tailored PRISMA approaches on the findings from objective 1, as well as on our experience with conducting Cochrane LSRs. Results: We identified 108 living publications relating to 32 LSRs. Of the 108 publications, 7% were protocols, 24% were base versions (i.e., the first version), 62% were partial updates (i.e., does not include all typical sections of an SR), and 7% were full updates (i.e., includes all typical sections of an SR). We identified six ways to reporting the study flow: base separately, each update separately (38%); numbers not reported (32%); latest update separately, all previous versions combined (20%); base separately, all updates combined (7%); latest update version only (3%); all versions combined (0%). We propose recording in detail the results of the searches to keep track of all identified records. For structuring the flow diagram, we propose using one of four approaches. Conclusion: We identified six ways for reporting the study flowthrough the different phases of the review for the different update versions. We propose to document in detail the study flow for the different search updates and select one of our four tailored PRISMA diagram approaches to present that study flow.

Authors

Kahale LA; Elkhoury R; El Mikati I; Pardo-Hernandez H; Khamis AM; Schünemann HJ; Haddaway NR; Akl EA

Journal

F1000Research, Vol. 10, , pp. 192–192

Publisher

F1000 Research Ltd

Publication Date

March 8, 2021

DOI

10.12688/f1000research.51723.1

Associated Experts

Holger Schunemann

Professor Emeritus, Faculty of Health Sciences

Visit profile

View published work (Non-McMaster Users)

Contact the Experts team

Get technical help

Provide website feedback