Motivational design for web-based instruction in health professions education: Protocol for a systematic review and directed content analysis (Preprint) Journal Articles

Web-based instruction plays an essential role in health professions education (HPE) by facilitating learners’ interactions with educational content, teachers, peers, and patients when they would not be feasible in person. Within the unsupervised settings where web-based instruction is often delivered, learners must effectively self-regulate their learning to be successful. Effective self-regulation places heavy demands on learners’ motivation, so effective web-based instruction must be designed to instigate and maintain learners’ motivation to learn. Models of motivational design integrate theories of motivation with design strategies intended create the conditions for motivated engagement. Teachers can use such models to develop their procedural and conceptual knowledge in ways that help them to design motivating instruction in messy real-world contexts. Studies such as randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and other quasi-experimental designs that compare different motivational design strategies play a critical role in advancing models of motivational design. Synthesizing the evidence from those studies can identify effective strategies and help teachers and researchers understand the mechanisms governing why strategies work, for whom, and under what circumstances.

The planned review aims to analyze how studies comparing motivational design strategies for web-based instruction in HPE support and advance of models of motivational design by: (1) controlling for established risks to internal validity, (2) leveraging authentic educational contexts to afford ecological validity, (3) drawing on established theories of motivation, (4) investigating a wide breadth of motivational constructs, and (5) analyzing mediators and moderators of strategy effects.

The planned review will utilize database searching, registry searching, and hand searching to identify studies comparing motivational design strategies for web-based instruction, delivered to learners in HPE. Studies will be considered from 1990 onwards. Two team members will independently screen studies and extract data from included studies. During extraction, we will record information on the design characteristics of studies, the theories of motivation they are informed by, the motivational constructs they target, and the mediators and moderators they consider.

We have executed our database searches and have begun screening titles and abstracts.

By appraising the characteristics of studies that have focused on the motivational design of web-based instruction in HPE, the planned review will produce recommendations that will ensure impactful programs of future research in this crucial educational space.

PROSPERO #CRD42022359521