Home
Scholarly Works
Pollock on Practical Reasoning
Chapter

Pollock on Practical Reasoning

Abstract

The American epistemologist John Pollock has implemented computationally an architecture for a rational agent which he calls OSCAR. OSCAR models both practical and theoretical (or epistemic) reasoning. I argue that Pollock’s model of practical reasoning, which has seven components, is superior not only to the two-component belief-desire model stemming from Aristotle, but also to the three-component belief-desire-intention model developed especially by the contemporary American philosopher Michael Bratman. Despite its advantages, Pollock’s model of practical reasoning is incomplete in at least three respects: it is solipsistic, it is egoistic and it is unsocial.

Authors

Hitchcock D

Book title

Argumentation Library

Volume

30

Pagination

pp. 215-224

Publication Date

January 1, 2017

DOI

10.1007/978-3-319-53562-3_13
View published work (Non-McMaster Users)

Contact the Experts team